A Bestop "Replace-A-Top" uses heavier fabric and thicker plastic in the windows. Fabric weight is rated by how much it weighs per square yard. Replace-A-Top fabric weighs 18 ounces a square yard, The Replay by Pavement Ends weighs 15 ounces a square yard. This is not too much of a difference. The biggest difference is in the windows which are twice as thick on the Bestop Replace-A-Top. Pavement Ends tops carry a one year warranty vs Replace-A-Top's two year. For an economical top that will last you at least a couple of years, the Replay is hard to beat, especially if you need door skins. If you want a little more quality, less road noise and a longer life out of the top, invest in the Replace-A-Top. If you want the best top for your Wrangler, by far the quietest, check out the
Bestop Sailcloth Jeep Soft Tops. If you don't require half door skins, they start at $451.99.